My Mom’s Magic Orange Cookies

It’s wonderful how food can evoke memories. My mom used to make a big batch of these cookies at Christmas, Easter and other special occasions. It’s a recipe she developed herself and perfected over the decades. When I moved to England, I took her recipe back with me. However, I struggled to recreate it and finally figured out how to convert the Canadian ingredients into ones I could find in the UK, namely the flour and vegetable shortening/lard. It was an ongoing project that my mother and I enjoyed working on.

I lost my mom only a few months ago and I miss her every day. In the midst of dealing with my grief, my thoughts somehow reverted to this recipe and all of the times we made it together as well as the conversations we had about adapting it to the UK when I moved away. I know I won’t ever have this experience with my mom again but I can keep her memory alive with sights, tastes and smells. And I can pass on the recipe to my son, who loves to bake with me. Some of the best moments we have together are in the kitchen so we made my mom’s recipe together for this blog post.

Cookies on Rack

We always called them cookies, although they are a bit like cupcakes or muffins. In fact, these cookies never really had a name. We just gobbled them up before we could think about identifying them into a specific category. It was only when my niece Amanda once asked my mom for her “magic” cookies that I came up with the name for the recipe. They have a whole cup of orange juice in them so I added “orange” to the name. So there you have it… My Mom’s Magic Orange Cookies.

Cookies on plate


4 eggs
400g (2 cups) sugar
220g Cookeen (for the UK) or Crisco vegetable shortening, left out at room temperature
250ml (1 cup) orange juice, no pulp
700g “Canadian & Very Strong White Bread Flour” (available at Waitrose)
[For North America, use 4-½ cups all purpose flour]
8 teaspoons baking powder
Icing sugar

You will also need about 40 cake cases/cupcake liners.

Preheat the oven to 190°C (170°C for fan-assisted ovens) / 375°F.

In a very large bowl, mix the eggs, sugar, shortening and orange juice with a wooden spoon. There will be some lumps from the Cookeen/shortening but don’t worry too much about it at this stage. The cookies will have a subtle orange flavour. If you want a stronger taste, you can grate some orange zest into the mixture.


Cookie Dough

UK readers, make sure you use strong flour, ideally “Canadian & Very Strong White Bread Flour” from Waitrose. UK “plain flour” won’t work. In a separate bowl, sift the flour and baking powder. Add these to the egg mixture. Keep mixing until all the ingredients are blended. The batter will be thick and sticky.

Unbaked cookies

Scatter some flour onto a plate and some icing sugar on a separate plate. The mixture is sticky so you may want to use a spoon to scoop it up. However, I find that working with your hands gets the best results so dust some flour on them and grab a handful of the batter. Yes, it will be gooey. Dip some into the flour on the plate to make it less sticky. Then roll in the icing sugar. Plop into a cake case/cupcake liner.

Repeat until you have filled a baking tray with all of the cake cases/liners. My oven tray holds 20, so I only had to bake two batches.

Bake for about 15-16 minutes, until the cookies rise and have just started to turn golden. Don’t wait until they are too crispy at the top.

Magic Orange Cookie

Makes 40 cookies. I suppose you can halve the recipe if you wish to make only 20, but I’ve never had to. These cookies are very addictive and will go quite fast!

The cookies came out great but more importantly, I enjoyed sharing this baking experience with my son. My mom would have been proud.

Unless otherwise noted, I am the legal copyright holder of the content and images on this blog. Please contact me for permission if you wish to use, reprint or publish any material.

7 thoughts on “My Mom’s Magic Orange Cookies

  1. I was thinking about Mom’s “cookie” recipe these past few days, wanting to bake them myself. In fact, I bought most of the the ingredients yesterday. How coincidental! Jason and Amanda (magic cookies) love them, and I will surprise them with a batch soon. I love that you made them, dear sis! I miss Mom too.
    From across the pond,
    Carmelina 🙂

      • Hug back! Your sharing of this recipe made me so happy. 🙂 BTW, I also sprinkle some additional icing sugar on the cookies once they are baked and cooled. Enjoy! xxoo.

  2. So when your son shares it, will he change the name to “Nonna’s Magic Orange Cookies”? 🙂 My mom always added extra orange zest (or lemon, she really preferred baking her cookies with lemon) and icing when ready 🙂 I’ll give this one a try soon and let you know how it goes 🙂

    • Yes, I think some extra orange zest would be good. It’s a good cookie for icing too. 🙂
      I think they’ll always have “magic” in the name… it’s magical how such a gooey batter can turn into a soft, spongy cookie.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.